Search for any business or category in Fire Island

Top Rated Fire Island Restaurants

Le Dock

Fresh Flavor by the Bay

60 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.8(105)•

$$$ • Seafood

Kismet Market

3 star Grocery Restaurant

Corner Of Oak Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.3(13)•

$$ • Grocery

Cherry Grove Pizza

Savor the Slice at Cherry Grove Pizza

179 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.8(38)•

$$ • Pizza

Canteen

2 star Diner Restaurant in Fire Island

Harbor Park, Fire Island, NY

2.4(41)•

$$ • Diners

Floyd's

5 star American Restaurant

Bayview Walk, Fire Island, NY

4.5(21)•

$$ • American

Island Pantry

4 star Convenience Store in Fire Island

92 Bayview Ave E, Fire Island, NY

4.3(6)•

$ • Convenience Stores

New Fire Island Restaurants

Le Dock

Fresh Flavor by the Bay

60 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.8(105)•

$$$ • Seafood

The Cheesecake Factory

The Cheesecake Factory: Menu for every craving

Where Every Meal Feels Like Home

90 W Main St, Babylon, NY

4.0(166)•

$$ • Italian

Naz's Halal Food- Deer Park

Family Flavors, Quality Ingredients

1171 Deer Park Ave, North Babylon, NY

3.8(163)•

$ • Halal

Mediterranean Express

Taste the Mediterranean, savor the moment.

625 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY

3.9(122)•

$$ • Greek

Khyber Grill & Gyro

Savor the Flavors of Khyber

270 Spur Dr S, Bay Shore, NY

3.5(96)•

$ • Halal

Popular Fire Island Restaurants

Le Dock

Fresh Flavor by the Bay

60 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.8(105)•

$$$ • Seafood

Cherry Grove Pizza

Savor the Slice at Cherry Grove Pizza

179 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.8(38)•

$$ • Pizza

Kismet Market

3 star Grocery Restaurant

Corner Of Oak Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY

3.3(13)•

$$ • Grocery

Canteen

2 star Diner Restaurant in Fire Island

Harbor Park, Fire Island, NY

2.4(41)•

$$ • Diners

Floyd's

5 star American Restaurant

Bayview Walk, Fire Island, NY

4.5(21)•

$$ • American

Island Pantry

4 star Convenience Store in Fire Island

92 Bayview Ave E, Fire Island, NY

4.3(6)•

$ • Convenience Stores

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

Fresh Flavors, Crafted Cocktails

70 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY

4.2(776)•

$$ • Mexican

Tellers An American Chophouse

Steaks, Seafood, and Timeless Elegance

605 Main St, Islip, NY

3.9(789)•

$$$$ • Steakhouses

Swell Taco

Tacos with a California twist

135 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY

4.1(801)•

$$ • Mexican

Bubba’s Burrito Bar

Burritos with a California twist

513 Main St, Islip, NY

4.0(678)•

$$ • Tacos

Brownstones Coffee - West Islip

Savor Every Sip and Bite

306 Union Blvd, West Islip, NY

4.2(645)•

$$ • Breakfast & Brunch

Salt & Barrel

Shuck, Sip, and Savor the Shore

61 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY

4.0(565)•

$$ • Seafood

Barrique Kitchen & Wine Bar

Savor global bites and fine wines

69 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY

4.0(584)•

$$ • Tapas Bars

Tullulah's

Tullulah's: Flavors of Local Seasons

12 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY

4.1(505)•

$$ • Tapas/Small Plates

Del Fuego

Bold Flavors, Fresh Tex-Mex Vibes

117 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY

3.7(565)•

$$ • Tex-Mex

Oconee East Diner

Taste the tradition at Oconee East Diner

749 Montauk Hwy, Islip, NY

4.0(502)•

$$ • Diners

View

Dining with a View of the Bay

3 Consuelo Pl, Oakdale, NY

3.7(534)•

$$$ • Seafood

Island Mermaid

Where Ocean Meets Flavor

780 Bay Wlk, Ocean Beach, NY

3.4(334)•

$$$ • New American

Whalers

Perfectly Crafted, Right on the Water

124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY

3.9(431)•

$$$ • Bars

Local Burger

Burgers Made with Local Love

62 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY

3.8(443)•

$$ • Burgers

Toast Coffeehouse

Brunch Bliss Awaits You at Toast

9 S Park Ave, Bay Shore, NY

4.1(431)•

$$ • Breakfast & Brunch

Americano Pie Bar

Savory Pies and Cocktails Awaits

517 Main St, Islip, NY

4.1(393)•

$$ • Italian

Nicky's On The Bay

Catch the Flavor at Nicky's Bay

150 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY

2.9(433)•

$$$ • Seafood

The Shed Restaurant

Brunch at its best in West Sayville

21 Main St, West Sayville, NY

4.3(429)•

$$ • American

Babylon Burger Bar

Bite into flavor at Babylon Burger Bar

1 W Main St, Babylon, NY

3.8(382)•

$$ • Burgers

Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant

Bayfront Seafood and Stunning Views

1 Bungalow Walk, Ocean Beach, NY

3.2(231)•

$$$ • Seafood

fatfish on The Water

Fresh Flavors with Stunning Views

28 Cottage Ave, Bay Shore, NY

3.5(377)•

$$$ • Seafood

Aji 53

Savor the fusion, enjoy the vibe

53 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY

3.9(351)•

$$ • Sushi Bars

koiKOKORO

Heartfelt Flavors of Japan & Korea

501 Main St, Islip, NY

4.5(339)•

$$ • Japanese

Tres Palms

Fresh Bites, Coastal Vibes

16 East Ct, Babylon, NY

3.2(360)•

$$ • New American

12 3 4 5…34 Next

The Giftly Advantage

With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Restaurants gift card with the flexibility of money.

100% satisfaction guaranteed

No wasted balance

Easy to customize

Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later

Send with a personalized greeting card

3 easy ways to redeem the gift

Send a Gift for Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

Visiting a restaurant is more than just about savouring delectable cuisine. It's about immersing yourself in the unique ambiance, bonding over shared tables, and creating unforgettable memories. Each restaurant offers its own unique charm, inviting you to partake in a culinary journey that will tantalize your tastebuds and leave you longing for more.

Turkuaz Grill
Turkuaz Grill offers an exquisite Mediterranean culinary experience, making it a must-visit for all food enthusiasts.
Rincon Criollo
Rincon Criollo boasts of its smoked pork chops, providing a tantalizing treat for meat lovers.
Vittorio's Italian Steak House
At Vittorio's Italian Steak House, you'll be charmed by excellent service and delectable Italian cuisine.
Maple Tree BBQ
Experience the best of BBQ in a serene setting at Maple Tree BBQ.
Se-Port Delicatessens
Se-Port Delicatessens offers an exceptional sandwich selection, perfect for a quick, satisfying bite.
Salumi Tapas & Wine Bar
Bask in a delightful mix of flavors at Salumi Tapas & Wine Bar, where you can create your own cheese and meat board.
Slurp Ramen
Get your ramen fix at Slurp Ramen, known for its signature slurp smooth.
Brownstones Coffee - Amityville
Experience the joy of waiting for an extraordinary coffee creation at Brownstones Coffee - Amityville.
Vauxhall
Experience the vegetarian delight, the Impossible Burger, at Vauxhall. Perfect for a guilt-free indulgence.

Descriptions, images, reviews and other business information on this page have not been verified by Giftly or Sunrise Bank.

Browse Other Categories for Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

Other Business Categories

Universal Giftly's

Any Restaurant

Gift up to $1,000 and let them choose where to spend it.
The thoughtfulness of a gift card with the freedom and flexibility of a Giftly.

Buy an Any Restaurant Gift

Any Store

Shop ‘til they drop, anywhere they want

248k stores nationwide

Universal Gift

Any Nail Salon

A mani-pedi at their favorite spot

27k nail salons nationwide

Universal Gift

Any Bar

Drinks on you! Wherever they choose

32k bars nationwide

Universal Gift

Any Place

Their favorite place, or a new spot

Any location nationwide

Universal Gift

Help

If you have questions, need help, or want to modify, resend, or cancel a gift, please see our Support Center, where you can access an array of self-service tools and our FAQ.

For other questions or issues, please contact support@giftly.com.

Gift Disclosure

The Giftly Prepaid Gift is redeemed for money through the Giftly website. It is not issued, endorsed, or accepted by any third-party merchant (including any third-party merchant explicitly referenced in this Giftly Prepaid Gift), and is not covered by the CARD Act. Giftly Prepaid Gifts never expire and there are no inactivity fees. Please see the Giftly Prepaid Gift Agreement for the complete terms.

Gift Cards

Buy a Gift for Restaurants in Fire Island

Top Rated Fire Island Restaurants

New Fire Island Restaurants

Popular Fire Island Restaurants

The Giftly Advantage

Send a Gift for Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

Turkuaz Grill

Rincon Criollo

Vittorio's Italian Steak House

Maple Tree BBQ

Se-Port Delicatessens

Salumi Tapas & Wine Bar

Slurp Ramen

Brownstones Coffee - Amityville

Vauxhall

Browse Other Categories for Restaurants in Fire Island, NY

Other Business Categories

Universal Giftly's

Any Restaurant

Help

Gift Disclosure