Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill Gift & Greeting Card

Buy a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to spend it at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill. Delivered in a customized greeting card by email, mail or printout.

Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill
Gift & Greeting Card

Buy a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to spend it at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill.

Delivered in a customized greeting card by email, mail or printout.

Giftly Gift Card
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill

Gift Amount

Gift Design

The Giftly GuaranteeSatisfaction Guaranteed
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill in Mendham gift card

Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill

Yelp Rating - 3.2 stars
179 reviews onYelp logo
(973) 543-7675
Location353 Mendham Rd W, Mendham, NJ
CategoriesSteakhouses

Is this your business?

Learn more about Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill

updated: October 07, 2024
Price$$$
Year Established1933
Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill map location
CUSTOMER REVIEWS
Joe I.
Yelp Rating - 5 stars06/05/2024
This has been my favorite restaurant for the last 50 years. Old school ambiance with a very cool bar downstairs. The food is spectacular. Maryanne and... read review
Al M.
Yelp Rating - 1 stars08/18/2024
The food is sub-par. The service is spotty. The prices are high. I just went for the first time in years and now I remember why I waited so long. It will be... read review
Susan K.
Yelp Rating - 1 stars08/29/2024
Awful, Awful and more Awful. The salad was brown lettuce, the steak was a bit overdone as it was not juicy and definitely not tender.The dessert was not... read review
HOURS
MonClosed
Fri5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
TueClosed
Sat5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Wed5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Sun5:00 PM - 9:00 PM
Thu5:00 PM - 9:00 PM

Business Description

Located in Mendham, NJ, Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill is a unique steakhouse that combines history and great food. Established in the 1920s as a speakeasy, it continues to draw in customers with its tradition and charm, now run by the founder's grandchildren.

  • Ambiance: Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill has a cozy, family-oriented environment filled with history, making it an inviting place for everyone.
  • Cuisine: The restaurant specializes in dry-aged steaks, Maine lobster, and handcrafted pastas, all made from high-quality ingredients.
  • Highlights: Enjoy the unique experience of ordering upon entering and relaxing at a speakeasy-style bar while your meal is prepared.

Guests appreciate the opportunity to enjoy drinks at the original Prohibition-era bar before heading to the upstairs dining room for a delightful meal. Each dish is cooked to order, ensuring freshness and quality. Sammy's tradition of personalized service makes each dining experience memorable, welcoming friends and families alike to create new memories in a place steeped in rich history.

Gift Tips

  • Engage with Mary Ann when placing your order, as she can share interesting stories about the restaurant's history as a former speakeasy.
  • For a truly delightful dining experience, try the Maine lobster which is a popular favorite among many guests.
  • Don't miss the dry-aged steaks, particularly the 6 oz filet, which is reported to be cooked to perfect medium rare and consistently gets high praise.
  • If you're in the mood for pasta, the Penne Vodka is an excellent choice and has received positive feedback for its flavor.
  • Enjoy drinks at the downstairs bar while you wait for your meal; it's a great spot to relax and soak in the ambiance.
Click here to send a gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill

Great Alternatives

Buy a Gift & Greeting Card for Village Wine & Liquors: Village Wine & Liquors in Mendham is a hidden gem for wine connoisseurs and spirit enthusiasts, offering a carefully curated selection that promises to delight every palate.

Check out a Chicken Kitchen Giftly: Chicken Kitchen offers a delicious array of flavorful and freshly prepared chicken dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving.

Descriptions, images, reviews and other business information on this page were collected by third-parties and have not been verified by Giftly or Sunrise Bank.

The Giftly Advantage

With Giftly you strike a perfect balance, the thoughtfulness of a Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill gift card with the flexibility of money.
  • Easy to buy online. Have it delivered now or later
  • Send it with a personalized greeting card
  • 3 easy ways for your recipient to redeem the gift
100% Satisfaction Gauranteed
No wasted balance
Easy to customize

How it works

  1. You customize a gift
    Gift up to $1,000 with the suggestion to use it at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill. Delivered in a personalized greeting card.
  2. They receive the gift
    Gifts can be sent by email, SMS*, mail or you can print it yourself.
  3. They enjoy it!
    They redeem the gift on our website and choose to deposit the funds in their bank account, Paypal account or to have a Visa Gift Card mailed to them.
They can spend the money at Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill or anywhere else they like!

You might also consider...

Help

If you have questions, need help, or want to modify, resend, or cancel a gift, please see our Support Center, where you can access an array of self-service tools and our FAQ.For other questions or issues, please contact support@giftly.com.

Gift Disclosure

The Giftly Prepaid Gift is redeemed for money through the Giftly website. It is not issued, endorsed, or accepted by any third-party merchant (including any third-party merchant explicitly referenced in this Giftly Prepaid Gift), and is not covered by the CARD Act. Giftly Prepaid Gifts never expire and there are no inactivity fees. Please see the Giftly Prepaid Gift Agreement for the complete terms.